Choosing Your Ideal Hearth: A Guide to Fireplace Types
Whether you’re undertaking a fireplace renovation or introducing an entirely new fireplace to your home, you might find yourself surprised by the sheer variety of options available. The four primary categories of fireplaces are wood-burning, gas, electric, and ethanol, with each encompassing further subcategories. This complexity can make the decision-making process more perplexing than it needs to be.
To simplify your understanding, we’ve dissected the common types of fireplaces, highlighting their respective pros and cons to empower you to make an informed choice.
Fireplace Varieties: More Than Just Aesthetics
Selecting a fireplace extends beyond merely choosing a look for your home. The decision between options such as wood-burning, gas, electric, and ethanol fireplaces can profoundly influence the initial installation cost, long-term operational expenses, and even the comfort level of your living space.
Want more home renovation tips and inspiration? Sign up for our free daily newsletter for the latest how-tos, renovation guides, and more!
Wood-Burning Fireplaces
When many people envision a fireplace, they picture a traditional wood-burning hearth, a fixture that has graced homes for centuries. You can almost conjure the distinctive scents and sounds of burning wood.
While wood undeniably serves as an excellent fuel source for a fireplace, these units are typically expensive and demand consistent maintenance and upkeep to ensure their safety and operational efficiency. Although the comfort and charm of a crackling wood fire are unparalleled, you can achieve greater efficiency with other fireplace types at a significantly lower cost. However, if you own or have access to wooded land, a bit of effort can provide you with an abundant heat source.
Types of Wood-Burning Fireplaces:
- Open-hearth: These are the most traditional wood fireplaces, featuring a wide-open design that draws room air for combustion. While often the most aesthetically pleasing, they are among the least efficient.
- Closed-hearth: The primary focus of closed-hearth fireplaces is to heat your home. Their enclosed design allows them to be up to 10 times more efficient than open-hearth wood fireplaces, though they may lack some of the traditional charm and visual appeal.
- Wood fireplace inserts: These units can be installed into an existing fireplace opening to enhance its safety and efficiency.
- Prefabricated: These are simply wood-burning fireplaces that are constructed off-site for easier installation.
Pros:
- Beautiful appearance
- Can add value to your home
- Charming sound, sight, and smell during operation
- Abundant, free fuel source if you own or have access to wooded property
Cons:
- High-maintenance
- Requires screens to prevent ash and embers from exiting
- Can be dangerous if improperly installed or poorly maintained
- Expensive installation
- Less efficient than other fireplace options
How Much Do Wood Fireplaces Cost?
While wood fireplaces can offer a relatively inexpensive heat source over time, their upfront costs can be substantial. Installation could range from as little as $700, but more complex projects can exceed $30,000. However, the average cost for a wood fireplace installation is around $2,499.
Gas Fireplaces
Gas fireplaces are an immensely popular home heating solution. While many newly constructed homes feature gas fireplaces as a standard, conversion gas fireplace inserts are frequently used to revitalize older wood-burning fireplaces that are either unsafe or simply no longer desired.
For those unfamiliar, “gas” typically refers to natural gas, which is a more efficient fuel source for a fireplace than wood. If your home already has natural gas utility access, installing a gas fireplace can be relatively straightforward.
The most common types of gas fireplaces are vented and ventless. Vented gas fireplaces are more akin to wood-burning fireplaces, using a chimney or similar component to vent the firebox. Conversely, ventless gas fireplaces require no venting because the gas burns cleanly and does not produce carbon monoxide.
Types of Gas Fireplaces:
- B-vent: B-vent natural gas fireplaces draw combustion air from the room and vent it through a double-wall pipe connected to a chimney.
- Direct vent: Instead of using a chimney, a direct vent gas fireplace pulls combustion air from outside and releases exhaust directly back outside.
- Ventless: Ventless gas fireplaces have no vent. They combust indoor air, allowing them to circulate heat throughout the space more efficiently. Because they require no ventilation or chimneys, they can be installed in almost any location.
Pros:
- Higher energy efficiency compared to traditional wood-burning fireplaces
- Fewer harmful emissions than wood-burning fireplaces
- Low maintenance
- Still produces a real flame, unlike electric options
Cons:
- Heat production relies on gas supply, which could be interrupted
- Higher upfront cost than some other fireplace options
- Vented gas fireplaces require ventilation, which may need to be added if not already present
- Gas leaks are possible, though rare
How Much Do Gas Fireplaces Cost?
A gas fireplace installation can be significantly less expensive than a wood-burning fireplace, but you should still anticipate spending between $2,500 and $10,000. Installing a conversion gas fireplace unit can save you money if you already have a compatible wood-burning fireplace, with an average price of $3,000.
Electric Fireplaces
Electric fireplaces are the quickest and simplest type of fireplace to install. Likewise, they are often the easiest to operate. Most electric fireplaces can be wall-mounted and plugged into a standard outlet, providing a nearly immediate heat source.
Many electric fireplaces are even designed for portability, allowing you to easily move them from room to room. Since they can be plugged into standard outlets, this makes it convenient to quickly enhance the comfort of any room you’re using.
Electric fireplaces are generally inexpensive to install and operate, but they aren’t directly comparable to gas and wood-burning fireplaces. The primary drawback of an electric fireplace is the absence of a real flame—a feature many consumers seek in a fireplace. Additionally, they are not functional during a power outage, whereas a gas or wood-burning fireplace would remain operational.
Types of Electric Fireplaces:
- Wall-mounted: These fireplaces are permanently affixed to the wall.
- Inset: These electric fireplaces are installed within the wall rather than on it, leading to a more complex, often costlier installation.
- Stove-style: These portable electric fireplaces mimic the appearance of an old wood-burning stove and can be moved between rooms.
- Basket-style: These electric fireplace units emulate the look of antique cast-iron fire baskets.
- TV stand: While seemingly unconventional, these are simply TV stands with integrated electric fireplaces.
Pros:
- Very easy installation
- Very energy efficient with no heat loss
- Low maintenance and incredibly safe
- Easily adjustable to your preferences
Cons:
- Doesn’t produce a real flame
- Doesn’t offer as much heat as gas or wood options
- No heat source during a power outage
- Not as sensory as a wood-burning fireplace (no natural aromas, sounds, or sights)
How Much Do Electric Fireplaces Cost?
With electric fireplaces, you avoid the high installation costs associated with gas and wood-burning models, as they don’t actively burn a fuel source. In most cases, they can simply be mounted and plugged in, significantly reducing upfront expenses. On average, electric fireplaces cost $700, but prices can range from $200 to $10,000, given the wide array of available styles.
Ethanol Fireplaces
Ethanol fireplaces represent a modern heating solution that utilizes an exceptionally clean-burning fuel source. A relatively new fireplace option, they are also frequently marketed as bio fireplaces or bioethanol fireplaces.
The fuel source, ethanol, is an alcohol-based fuel most commonly derived from corn. Burning ethanol produces a real flame without the harmful emissions associated with other fireplace fuel sources. Consequently, ethanol fireplaces do not require ventilation.
Types of Ethanol Fireplaces:
- Freestanding: Much like portable electric fireplaces, these lightweight ethanol options can be moved from room to room.
- Tabletop: Smaller, portable ethanol fireplaces designed for use on a tabletop, offering ambiance and suitability for activities like roasting marshmallows.
- Built-in: Ethanol fireplaces can also be permanently integrated into a wall, similar to a gas fireplace. These integrated options often feature a glass front.
- Wall-mounted: Wall-mounted ethanol fireplaces offer a look similar to built-in units but with an easier, less invasive installation process.
Pros:
- No ventilation required
- More design options
- Low maintenance
- Clean-burning
- Produces a real flame
Cons:
- Lower heat production compared to other fireplace options
- Bioethanol fuel source is more expensive than gas or wood
- Limited flame control
- Not as safe as gas or electric options
How Much Do Ethanol Fireplaces Cost?
Ethanol fireplaces are among the most affordable in terms of upfront costs, with average installation expenses ranging between $700 and $1,400. However, because ethanol fuel is more expensive than other fuel sources, the long-term operational costs may eventually equalize the total cost of the fireplace.
How to Choose the Right Fireplace for Your Home
Now that you understand the key differences between wood-burning, gas, electric, and ethanol fireplaces, how do you determine which is best suited for your home? Here are the factors you should consider:
- Installation costs: One of the most critical factors in choosing the best fireplace for you is your budget, as the associated costs vary significantly. Once you’ve established your spending limit, you can explore options that fit within it.
- Operational costs: Each fireplace type on this list uses a different energy source to generate heat, and each fuel source incurs costs. Even wood, which might seem cheap (or free if you have timber on your property), requires considerable physical labor, which you might lack the time or energy for.
- Maintenance: You should also consider the amount of maintenance you are willing to perform throughout the year, as each fireplace type has different maintenance requirements. For instance, wood-burning fireplaces demand a lot of cleaning and upkeep, while electric fireplaces require little to no maintenance.
- Utility access: Before setting your heart on a gas fireplace, verify with your utility company that your home has access to gas services.
- Building codes: While a wood-burning fireplace is a beautiful addition, some building codes do not permit them. Check your local regulations before making any plans.
- Ventilation: Many fireplaces on this list, such as gas and wood-burning, require ventilation. This can restrict where a fireplace can be installed in your home, or even whether it can be installed at all.
FAQ
What’s the easiest fireplace to install?
A wall-mounted electric fireplace is the easiest type to install and can readily be managed by any level of DIY enthusiast. Most wall-mounted electric fireplaces do not require hardwiring to a circuit and can simply be plugged into a standard electrical receptacle.
Which type of fireplace puts out the most heat?
Gas fireplaces are generally considered the most efficient for heat transfer. They boast higher BTUs (British Thermal Units) than wood-burning fireplaces and do not necessitate a chimney, where much of a wood-burning fireplace’s heat is lost. Ventless gas fireplaces are among the most efficient types, as they continuously circulate heat throughout the room with minimal to no loss.
What fireplace is the most cost-effective?
Electric fireplaces are often regarded as the most cost-effective option, as the combined cost of the unit, installation, and operation is lower than that of gas and wood-burning fireplaces. This lower cost is primarily due to the less involved installation of electric fireplaces, as many can simply be mounted to a wall and plugged into an outlet.